Are they obliged to do as he wishes?
#EXE220
No. They are to give careful and respectful attention to his recommendations and his reasons for them, but they are at full liberty to follow their own judgment in all cases.
Related questions
- #EXE218Suppose Congress wishes to know from the President something which he has not told them in his speech or messages, may they call upon him to communicate it? (Presidency and Executive Power)Yes, and if he does not think that the public good requires it to be kept secret, he always answers the call, and gives them the knowledge they requested, if he can do so.
- #EXE217When does he lay this information before Congress? (Presidency and Executive Power)After a first introductory address at the beginning of his term, he makes a full statement of it, usually on an annual basis, when they meet together in a joint session of congress, in what is usually...
- #EXE221Is it desirable that the Congress should always comply with the advice of the President? (Presidency and Executive Power)No; for then his advice would, in time, come to have the authority of a command; it would be the President and not Congress who was legislating our laws; and the liberty of the country would be in the...
- #EXE216Does he know what is the state of the nation better than Congress? (Presidency and Executive Power)Yes; his office is such that he is better situated for knowing it. Members of Congress reside in and represent only one State, but the President occupies a position of national authority. It is the du...
- #EXE215What are the regular duties of the President? (Presidency and Executive Power)The President must from time to time report to Congress concerning the state and affairs of the nation.
- #EXE219Does he do more than communicate information to the Congress? (Presidency and Executive Power)Yes; it is his duty also to recommend to them such actions as he believes will be for the advantage of the nation.